patching...
Update: Share Your Photos, News Tips and More! Follow Us on Facebook! »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Fountayne Lane Firefighter Response Times Reviewed

Contrary to claims that it took Lawrence Township volunteer firefighters up to 25 minutes to respond, official response records show that three fire engines were on scene within 12 minutes of firefighters first being alerted to the blaze.

 

It took Lawrence Township volunteer firefighters less than 12 minutes after they were first alerted to the blaze to get three fully-staffed fire engines on the scene of the inferno that destroyed one home and damaged two others on Fountayne Lane early Monday morning (Aug. 13), according to official response records obtained by Lawrenceville Patch.

The question of how long it took firefighters to respond was raised by readers of Patch’s previous coverage of the fire. Some readers on Monday posted comments alleging that it took firefighters as much as 25 minutes to arrive.

According to the official incident report from Mercer County Central Communications – the county agency responsible for dispatching and coordinating fire responses in Lawrence Township and most other municipalities in the county – the company in charge of monitoring the alarm system in the home at 126 Fountayne Lane called the county dispatch center at 12:20 a.m. Monday to report that the automated fire alarm system in the house had just gone off.

After being advised by the alarm monitoring company that a smoke detector had been activated, a 911 operator at Mercer County Central confirmed the address and then, at 12:22 a.m., dispatched the Slackwood and Lawrence Road volunteer fire companies to 126 Fountayne Lane to investigate the reason for the alarm activation.

Lawrence Township’s three fire companies are entirely volunteer, meaning that their firehouses are not manned around the clock like the stations of career – or paid – fire departments. Instead, volunteer firefighters – if they are available at the time – respond from their homes or wherever they might be when needed.

Four career firefighters who work 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Monday through Friday, excluding holidays, are currently employed by Lawrence Township to staff one fire engine during the work week when most volunteer firefighters are unavailable due to their full-time work commitments.

The township had planned to hire two additional firefighters this year to help ensure qualified personnel were on duty during the work week to drive the volunteers’ fire engines and operate their complex pumping systems – since only a limited number of volunteers are available to do so – but those positions are being eliminated as part of the layoffs that will occur at the end of this month as a result of the township’s ongoing financial problems.        

So Slackwood and Lawrence Road volunteer firefighters, awakened at 12:22 a.m. by the beeping of their fire company pagers, climbed out of bed, dressed and drove from their homes to their respective firehouses. Once at the firehouses, they donned they protective turnout gear and boarded their fire engines to make the drive to Fountayne Lane, which is located off Lawrence Station Road in the eastern-most corner of the township.

Lawrence Township Police Officer Shaun Sexton, meanwhile, was busy responding in his patrol car to check out a separate 911 call that township police happened to receive from the neighborhood at 12:20 a.m. reporting a possible vehicle fire on Fountayne Lane.

Not only did Sexton find a vehicle ablaze in the driveway, he arrived to find the entire house at 126 Fountayne Lane engulfed in flames, police said.

Sexton’s report of a “working structure fire” was relayed by Lawrence police to Mercer County Central Communications, which in turn, at 12:24 a.m., alerted already-responding Slackwood and Lawrence Road volunteers and also dispatched additional crews from Lawrenceville Volunteer Fire Co., Prospect Heights and Pennington Road volunteer fire companies from Ewing Township, and Hamilton Township Fire District 4.

In Lawrence Township and many other municipalities served by volunteer firefighters, as a matter of safety, a fire apparatus must be manned by a minimum of four firefighters before it can respond.

Hamilton’s Ladder 14 – the only unit to respond to Fountayne Lane Monday morning that was staffed by career firefighters – left its firehouse on East State Street at 12:26 a.m., according to response records.

Also responding at 12:26 a.m. with a full crew of volunteers, just four minutes after the first dispatch, was Lawrence Road’s Engine 22 from its firehouse on Route 206. Slackwood’s Engine 21 left its quarters on Slack Avenue, also fully-staffed, at 12:27 a.m., while Lawrenceville’s Telesquirt 23 responded with a full crew from its Phillips Avenue firehouse at 12:29 a.m.

At 12:29 a.m., according to response records, Lawrence Road Fire Chief Shaun Dlabik arrived on the scene and radioed that flames were shooting through the roof of 126 Fountayne Lane. Less than a minute later, Dlabik was joined on the scene by Lawrenceville Fire Chief Gary Wasko and Slackwood Fire Chief Michael Oakley.

At 12:33 a.m., after maneuvering along the narrow lane lined with parked cars that is the only way in and out of the development, Engine 21, Telesquirt 23 and Engine 22 all arrived on the scene one after the other, according to response records.

Ladder 14 arrived at 12:34 a.m., followed by Lawrenceville’s Ladder Tower 23 at 12:38 a.m., Slackwood’s Snorkel 21 at 12:39 a.m. and Lawrence Road’s Rescue 22 at 12:41 a.m.

Prospect Heights' Engine 31 and Pennington Road’s Rescue 32 arrived a few minutes after that.

Firefighting efforts were chaotic in the first minutes, as different hoselines were dragged into position to spray water on the neighboring homes being threatened by the raging flames and firefighters set up the stabilizing jacks to raise Telesquirt 23’s 65-foot ladder and Ladder 14’s 104-foot aerial so water could be rained down upon the engulfed house.

Engine 21’s onboard 800-gallon tank and Telesquirt 23’s own 500-gallon tank supplied the initial water used to fight the flames. After that, thousands of gallons of water were supplied by three hydrants in the neighborhood. Nearly 2,000 feet of large diameter hose was laid and used to flow water from those hydrants to the fire engines.

By 12:41 a.m., according to response records, the roof at the rear of 126 Fountayne Lane had collapsed. A propane cylinder on the rear deck also exploded.

The blaze was officially declared under control at 1:11 a.m. but firefighters continued to flow water on the smoldering ruins of 126 Fountayne Lane for several hours.

The cause of the blaze remains under investigation by Lawrence Township police and fire officials, along with the Mercer County Fire Marshal’s Office and the Mercer County Prosecutor’s Office.

    

Response Times:

Shown in the chart below are the various pieces of firefighting apparatus that responded to the blaze, along with the time that each unit was dispatched, went responding and arrived at the fire scene. Also shown are the times for the chief officers of each of Lawrence Township's three volunteer fire companies.

Other units that responded (such as fire company deputy chiefs and other officers, ambulances, PSE&G utility crews and investigators) are not listed in this chart.

All times are taken directly from the official incident report generated by Mercer County Central Communications.

All entries are listed in military time, with 00 representing 12 a.m. Times are given in the hour/minute/second format.    

Unit

Dispatched

Responding

Arrived

Chief 22

00:22:11

00:23:59

00:29:17

Chief 21

00:22:11

00:24:47

00:30:29

Chief 23

00:22:11

00:25:18

00:30:21

Engine 22

00:22:11

00:26:38

00:33:59

Engine 21

00:22:11

00:27:01

00:33:48

Telesquirt 23

00:24:40

00:29:38

00:33:32

Rescue 22

00:22:11

00:31:29

00:41:57

Ladder Tower 23

00:24:40

00:31:36

00:38:54

Snorkel 21

00:22:11

00:32:30

00:39:10

 

 

 

 

Ladder 14

00:24:40

00:26:23

00:34:11

Engine 31

00:24:40

00:31:24

00:43:15

Rescue 32

00:24:40

00:32:37

00:46:24

Fire Station Identifiers:

  • Station 21: Slackwood Volunteer Fire Co., 21 Slack Ave., Lawrence Township
  • Station 22: Lawrence Road Volunteer Fire Co., 1252 Lawrence Rd., Lawrence Township
  • Station 23: Lawrenceville Volunteer Fire Co., 64 Phillips Ave., Lawrence Township
  • Station 14: Hamilton Township Fire District #4, 1805 E. State St., Hamilton Township
  • Station 31: Prospect Heights Volunteer Fire Co., 1660 Ninth St., Ewing Township
  • Station 32: Pennington Road Volunteer Fire Co., 1666 Pennington Rd., Ewing Township  
Related Topics: Fire and Lawrence Township

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:16 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

So assuming the official record is "accurate" it took them a long time to get water running from the fire hydrants into the fire engines and on to the house. I stood there for a good 15-20 minutes watching and waiting for them to start pumping significant amounts of water onto the fire. It was horrible watching the firefighters running a single hose of water from the ground for that 15-20 minutes before they got water running from 2 ladder trucks. Once the ladder trucks got running and you could see the huge hoses on the ground from the hydrants getting filled-up we all had a collected is of relief that it probably wasn't going to get worse but for those horrible minutes before that we were all worried that this fire was going to be an even bigger disaster. And BTW a friend of mine from the neighborhood just a couple of houses away from the fire called 911 a lot earlier than 12:22. He was even out there with a fire extinguisher trying to help put out the fire so the "official" record seems conveniently regular and not out of the ordinary.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ben

10:14 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

12:22 isn't when the call was made, it was the fire department was dispatched. Depending on the manner of the call (home or cell phone) you may or may not be transferred from one dispatch center to another (especially with cell phones). From the time 911 receives the call to the time the tones drop for the VOLUNTEER firefighters, there may be roughly 3 to 4 minutes. The reason is because the dispatcher must map the location of the incident and then determine which jurisdiction its in, and further, based on the nature of the call (in this case it was initially a fire alarm), which fire apparatus to dispatch (for example, it would be pointless to send a Brush Truck to a major accident on 95). I applaud the neighbor for helping, but this criticism has to stop. We firemen must arrive on scene safely to be of any good, just keep that in mind when you see us going somewhere.

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

11:25 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Liberty Green - did you have a stopwatch out and really "time" how long it took for water flow? Also, "Ladder Trucks" don't flow water. Ladder Truck crews go into fires without water looking for idiots like you that were too dumb to leave! And everyone has a neighbor, that knows a neighbor that called much earlier!

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

1:04 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Ah, and in the initial article, you posted this, "Liberty green neighbor

12:16 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

We're grateful to our first responders however they started pitting out fire about 25 minutes after first receiving our calls. I live close by & had to call twice. Also despite no traffic at 12:30am, they reached no less than 15-20 minutes on the scene. I know house could not have been saved but what if someone was trapped inside? We expect better response time & plan to complain to the township.

Comment_arrow

co2

10:05 pm on Friday, August 17, 2012

Here are a few realities for you:
#1. There once was a fire station, just across the railroad tracks in Lawrence Square Village, barely 3 minutes away from this fire. It was staffed by a paid driver during the day, with the intent that volunteers would respond to help. It closed years ago because no one was volunteering to staff it from the neighnorhood. This engine would have at least slowed the fire down before re-enforcements arrived.
#2. My educated guess is that all of you who plan to complain to the Township about the response time of the fire departments are the same ones who are FREAKED OUT when Lawrence Township does their budget review. And the ones SCREAMING about less government and fiscal responsibility. I am sure if you all pitched in, the township would put a staffed fire engine in the Training Center down the street from you. Would you all write a check, please?
#3. Firefighters are NOT Superman. The equipment takes time to drive to the scene, deploy, set up, and operate. Further, if you really want to get a feel for the process, I know these guys and I know that if you went over to the fire station (in a civil manner), they would be glad to demonstrate what it takes to set up to fight a fire.

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:27 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

PS: I'm not trying to disparage the firefighters themselves. They worked very hard to try and get things under control but someone's got to take a look at how a 911 call about a fire gets prioritized and manged and see if the procedures in place are not getting in the way of helping those who are in need. The police were in the neighborhood very quickly (first on the scene) as well but a police car is not equipped to put out these kinds of fires. There was a report that the trucks had a hard time getting to the fire once they reached the community and that doesn't surprise me since it's often difficult to get around the islands with a passenger car let alone a fire truck. For the life of me, I can't understand why people are allowed to park near those islands. Nor can I understand why any rational person would choose to park there since it seems that you'd be begging for someone to side-swipe you there. Also, I don't know if the fire trucks or the fire hydrants were the reason that it took so long to get the ladder trucks pumping water but someone's got to take a look at that as well. It could mean the difference between just filling out insurance claims or having to make an appointment with a funeral director.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Blueline

10:21 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Hey Neighbor, that huge complex to the rear of your development is named the John Dempster Fire Center. They have firefighter classes yearly. You certainly seem to have tremendous opinions about this so how about you sign up for a class and join the cause. It certainly seems like you have a lot to say about how things work (baseless knowledge of course) so learn the craft, climb aboard the truck, and help educate everyone who seem to be lacking your forethought.

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

11:26 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Liberty Green - any comment you type or any word that comes out of your mouth disparages anyone - especially the firefighters.

Joe smith

10:16 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

What a lot of people don't fully understand is that when you call 911 from a cell phone is does not always got right to that towns police deptartment. It hits the nearest cell phone tower and then could hit Hamilton police dispatcher, west Windsor police or state police dispatcher. Then if it hits one of those dispatch centers it has to be transferred to the proper town. (not saying the person or persons used cell phone) . I also googled the address of the fire to see what the development looked like and is it possible there is only one big water loop for fire hydrants, so wouldn't it be like running your washer while taking a shower and get low water pressure. Just a question iam no expert and could be way off.

Reply

Liberty Green Neighbor

11:14 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

@Blueline I'm not asserting any expertise I'm just saying that it took what seemed like a really long time for the fire department to get on scene from the time the 911 call was made. I'm not saying that they didn't respond as soon as they could when they were informed I'm saying that the way a 911 call is managed might be kind of a problem. This report only identifies when the firefighters were dispatched and not when 911 was notified and something between those 2 points may need to be fixed. And getting significant amounts of water on the fire also seemed to take a really long time and maybe something could be addressed there as well. And maybe people shouldn't be parking around the islands since that seems to have made it difficult for the firefighters to arrive sooner. No one person, no single institution is perfect and everybody has slip ups. My point is that if we collectively don't take the time to learn what went wrong and learn from that then we run the risk of slipping up again. The Liberty Green community should do something about the cars parked near the islands and maybe the emergency services of Lawrenceville could look at the fire hydrants and their equipment to make sure they are working as expected. Is there anything wrong with that?

Reply

Liberty Green Neighbor

11:28 am on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

@Ben Thanks very much for all the hard work you do to help your neighbors. I'm truly very gratefull. You save lives and I can think of no better thing to do for your community. I apologize if you feel that I was criticiszing your efforts. That was not my intention. I was there and witnessed your determination and the risks you take. I just have questions about how you guys were notified and why that seems to have taken so long. The neighbor in question used a land line so how does that get managed? Is there anything we can do when calling 911 to make sure you guys get the right information as soon as possible? Could the caller have added something that would have helped route the call more efficiently? Is there something we as a community could do about making it easier for you guys to get to a fire? I'm guessing that those cars around the island were the biggest issue. I don't want to blame anyone for anything I just want to make sure that if god forbid I have to make that call I do everything in my power to not get in the way of getting help to where it's needed and that if there's something that the township could review or help enforce that they do the same as well.

Thanks again for what you do!

Reply

SHSB

1:15 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

1. The original 911 call came in as an automatic alarm. I can tell you that the fire departments get hundreds of these calls a year. Automatic alarm. Alarm malfunctions. IMHO if you want these calls taken more seriously, more needs to be done to prevent false 911 calls via automatic alarms. My husband is a firefighter, and every time we hear automatic alarm as a dispatch we roll our eyes because they are almost always BS calls. Fines need to be assessed to repeat offenders for these automatic alarms. Then people would fix theri alarm systems, there would be less false alarms (bot that cried wolf, anyone?), and automatic alarm calls might be made a bigger priority. Only after PD arrived on scene was this upgraded to a fully involved structure fire, which would then cause mutual aid (other fire companies) to be called in.

2. Most 911 calls made from a cellphone are routed to a State police dispatcher who may or may not be familiar with your area. That dispatcher must then reroute the call to the appropriate municipality's dispatch center.

3. The dispatch reports, if I'm not mistaken, are electronically generated from the audio tapes recorded at the dispatch center, i.e., the actual dispatcher's phone lines. While there may be a way to alter the tapes and reports, in my 21 years as an emergency responder, I've never seen a way to do so.

Reply

SHSB

1:20 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

4. When complaining about response times, remember that people in general do not yield to the blue lights on volunteer vehicles, and often do not yield to our emergency vehicles. We can't get there any faster if the public won't let us by. Perhaps parking along the access road to this complex should be reviewed for safety and whether it adversely impacts response times. Remember that emergency vehicles are a lot wider than your personal vehicle. I have to wonder if some of the people that are complaining about response times here are the same people that complained when a fire truck was involved in an accident responding to a fire call a few months ago. Then, people complained that it was *just* a mulch fire and why were they going fast. Here we have a dispatch for an automatic alarm, and people complain they went too slow. These firefighters are damned if they do and damned if they don't.

5. Please remember that when a event like this happens, time seems to go slowly. One minute feels like ten.

Reply

SHSB

1:23 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

6. To those that complain about the length of time it takes to actually fill the hoses: fire hydrants MUST be flushed prior to filling hoses. If they are not flushed first, rocks, dirt, silt, and other debris will get into the hoses and clog them, or even worse, damage the pumping mechanism of the truck, rendering that truck inoperable. Yes, it takes time. To someone untrained, it may seem like a waste of time. To the fire department, it means the difference between pumping water on the fire or fixing 5 to 6-figure damage to an inoperable pumper.

Reply

Cowboy

1:37 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Heres a shout out to all the professional volunteers who at a moments notice are ready to risk there lives for their fellow neighbors. Thanks from a grateful Lawrence resident.

Reply

VPPD

1:54 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

So roll your eyes wife of a firefighter answer this? are you saying that automatic fire alarm calls are made a less priority than other calls? I would really like to investigate that statement!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ricky Bobby

3:30 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

VPPD do you really think a volunteer fire fighter (who may have a full-time job) should or can drive with the same alacrity as responding to the 100s of fire alarms as they should to a working fire? Do you think police respond the same way for the 100's of burglar alarm as they do for an armed robbery? I cant tell you how many times I see volunteers trying to get to the station and cars not moving out of their way. Sometimes these guys are accused of driving too fast now they didn't drive fast enough. But you know what they are willing to leave their families in the middle of the night, not knowing if they will see them again because they are genuinely kind, courageous, caring people. I don't think , most people complaining on this forum has half the gumption it takes to be a firefighter for a week, yet alone a volunteer to ingrates like you VPPD. This township cant balance its current budget, if folks want an all paid department go for it. Good luck exceeding the 2% cap by another million dollars or so.

pridesouthof95

2:16 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

lets not forget to take in the fact that our town LOVES the oh mighity "PRINCETON" speed humps.... and that slows the responders down far more then the intended offenders! I saw a fire engine hit one on gedney at what I will call 10mph and it sounded like a bomb went off and the driver looked like he damn near lost his teeth. So that size of truck must slow down to about 3mph to make them and Im sure this street has about 10 either way you go! seconds count and when you have to stop every 50ft that takes time.

Reply

cathy g

2:49 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

There was a movement in April/May by Ewing to consolidate dispatch services into our police dispatch center. Puliti was supposed to be following up on that. Never saw anything about it here?? Mike, were you there? Are you still w/22? If so, I hope you are not taking the posts here to heart. I would want to see some reaction quotes from our elected officials... If you tried and got no where say so. Hey, did they find the dog?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Michael Ratcliffe

4:27 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

At the May 1 township council meeting, the possibility of Lawrence Township consolidating 911 call-taking and police dispatching with Ewing Township, Hopewell Township, Princeton Borough and Princeton Township was discussed. It was noted by the township manager during that meeting that an independent consultant had determined that such a consolidation was possible but that a lot of work still needed to be done before it could happen, particular with regard to the labor agreements that currently exist between the various municipalities and their respecting dispatching staff. For more details, read the story here: http://patch.com/A-tqGW)

VPPD

3:51 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Ricky Bobby no name calling please! Its started as an automatic then reported as a working fire! So next time you think a automatic isn't important and someone dies, you tell the families it wasn't a priority! you ingrate!

Reply

Chris pangaldi

3:57 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Hey Liberty Green Neighbor just a heads up.......Per map quest from 21 Slack ave (slackwood fire co.) to 126 Fountayne Ln (house fire) the fastest route is 9 minutes......So in case you don't understand then let me clarify.... The first Engine arrived about 11 mins 30 secs after the dispatch .........Hmmmmm pretty impressive in my eyes.....Keep counting beans

Reply
Comment_arrow

VPPD

4:44 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Chris you are correct very impressive. Great job to all of you!

Comment_arrow

LawrencevilleMom

10:04 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

And I can confirm that the arrival time in the chart is correct. The Slackwood truck was parked in front of my driveway, and there were several trucks already on the scene at that point. From the house in question, it takes 3 minutes just to get to the front of Liberty Green. The street has a wavy design specifically to "calm" traffic. I really want to say again that I think there should be no overnight parking on the street at all because that just adds to the problem.

VPPD

4:55 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Ricky Bobby and SHSB I agree an automatic burglar alarm has less priority than a armed robbery. But a fire is a fire and we are talking about life safety here how do make a statement about choosing priority? How do you sleep at night especially if you take an oath! shame on you!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

SHSB

7:46 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Shame on me? Really? My husband and I volunteer to respond at all hours of the day and night--and do respond at all hours of the day and night. Doesn't mean we don't respond to the fire alarms. We do, no matter how many times they go off in a day, week, month, or year. (What have you done lately--because you certainly haven't done this!) But the fact is that oftentimes several 911 calls come in at the same time, and the dispatchers must prioritize the calls. When a call comes in as an automatic alarm, we still respond with blue lights and then lights and sirens, even though there's greater than a 99% chance that it's a false alarm. These trucks don't stop on a dime; the faster we go the harder it is to stop, so we always have to mitigate the risk of speed with the risk of never even arriving and/or injuring ourselves in a crash on the way to a scene. The difference is that for a working structure fire, firefighters are generally willing to risk more. Even I understand that, as the wife of a firefighter. I don't think trucks should be responding "balls to the wall" to every automatic alarm. That's not in the best interests of the firefighters or the driving public. I've even said to my husband that if he is ever injured in an accident responding to or from one of the many repeat alarm offenders that I'd like to sue that offender for failure to fix their alarm and placing the firefighters at undue risk. (I won't, but I like the idea of it.)

Liberty Green Resident

6:57 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

I appreciate the efforts of the fire department and certainly do not criticize any of their work. In fact I am very grateful that they saved the other two house. I am a Liberty Green resident and don't live far from the scene. I saw it all happen. The thing that concerns me is the response system. This article mentions that the trucks were here in 12 minutes. This is not true. If the firefighters were sleeping at their homes then 12 minutes is impossible. If you think about it, a person has to get out of bed, put his clothes on, get in his own car, drive to the firestation, get in the trucks, then drive to scene. How can all this happen in 12 minutes. Even when the trucks arrived the firefighters couldn't get the hose going! They were not ready for this type of situation. They shouldn't have sent the volunteer firefighters if they were inexpierenced. Also SHSB said that cars don't yield for the emergency vehicle. BUT there wouldn't be many vehicles on the road at 12:30 am on a Sunday night. If you disagree with me, just remember. There were only a few people who saw everything. Many people came later. I was one of the ones that saw it all.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

11:40 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Liberty Green, you now "appreciate" the efforts of the fire department, yet in your first post (and you were the first person to post and discount the official records) you said, and I quote you, ["assuming the official record is "accurate" it took them a long time to get water running from the fire hydrants into the fire engines and on to the house. I stood there for a good 15-20 minutes watching and waiting for them to start pumping significant amounts of water onto the fire"]
I think a real public apology is in order. Also, a significant donation to ALL the volunteer fire departments is in order from you.

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

11:49 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I also wish to ask of you, did your "Neighbor who called earlier than the response" speak English without an accent? Were they very excited and nervous when they called? Did they call from a land-line phone or cell phone?

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

12:44 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Liberty Green, I feel you need to disappear from this website and the internet all-together. I'll happily explain why. You posted, "mentions that the trucks were here in 12 minutes. This is not true. If the firefighters were sleeping at their homes then 12 minutes is impossible. If you think about it, a person has to get out of bed, put his clothes on, get in his own car, drive to the firestation, get in the trucks, then drive to scene. How can all this happen in 12 minutes."
We all live close to our fire houses because we live in the town!
We also respond fast (within minutes) because this is our passion! Saving lives is our passion. Fighting fires and saving lives is what we do, because no-one else does it.

I think, if you live in the development, you shouldn't be second-guessing the FD. You should examine your own fire and life-safety systems, and make sure you and your family have a plan in place.

Most importantly, consider, the comments you post., This is the internet, and you never know whom you may upset. Any Information Technology professional that is a volunteer in emergency services would strongly advise you to ensure you either contribute to a department or stop posting any opinion.

Chris pangaldi

7:55 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Mr. Liberty green let me explain something since you just can't comprehend.........I live the furthest from the station at 3 blocks, two guys where staying at the station and the other two live less then 200yards......... Sooooooo hopefully you are smart enough to still follow me here! I was at the station in less then 2 minutes from dispatch and the rest of the crew was boarding the truck.......what does this mean for the uneducated??? This means the truck was on the road around the the 5 minute mark and on Scene around 12, sooooo this means 7 minutes on the road which is 2 minutes faster then map quest states...... Why 2 minutes less ?? Probably because we responded at emergency speed....... Get it yet???? By the way my name is posted if you need a better explanation , look me up

Reply

pridesouthof95

8:03 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Council really your not going to step in and back the people that save you millions of dollors in fire service but your going to back the chief of police who cost the twp thousands of dollors!!!! What a joke Greg when you run on a public safety ticket!!! Joke again all 3 fire companies are taking apps. Sign up or shut up!!!

Reply

justsaying

8:03 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

First your to fast now you to slow. Maybe one day they will understand or join up and help you get your trucks out at the "perfect time"

Reply

Phil McCrackin

8:18 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

MR PINGALDI U ARE ABSOLUTELY CORRECT. LIBERYY GREEN U ARE AL INCORRECT ITS NOT EVEN FUNNY WALK A DAY IN A FIRE FIGHTERS SHOES I GARENTEE U WON'T LAST..BECAUSE I EVEN TRIED AND COULDN'T DO IT MYSELF. MR LIBERTY I HOPE YOUR HOUSE DOESNT BURN BECAUSE I WOULDNT WANT THE FIRE FIGHTERS TO GET THERE " TO FAST"

Reply

Smokey

8:20 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Thank You Volunteer Citizen Firefighter. You ran into the fire, not many would do that.
My concern however is the skill set of our brave Fire Fighters. A police officer had to ask a resident the lactation the fire hydrant. What is the use of an own board data system that cannot tell a First Responder where the public services on a street are; there should be an App for that.
Where is the water? Once connected to the hydrant, the site Command asked for water from the Lawrence TWSP pumper truck, the firefighter replied it is on the way, and we watched the large diameter hose lay flat as the firefighter struggle with controls of the Lawrence TSWP pumper truck. Again over the radio we heard the site Command demand for the water. The same reply “it is on the way”. The “nearly two thousand feet” of large diameter hose lay flat. Finally, the pumper truck from Pennington TSWP took control of the line and still we waited as the operator made the connections. But water did flow and fill the large diameter hose many minutes later. And Lawrence’s truck stood by like a wet noodle.

Reply

Smokey

8:21 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Would the damages to the three homes been less had the water flowed earlier. I think it would have had a significant difference.
• Because of the layout, Fountayne Lane needs a clear disaster - action plan.
• A plan that is mindful of the one way in or out of Liberty Green.
• Cars are parked on the narrow street and at the medians.
• That First Responders data ports should locate things like hydrants; this would also prevent equipment from gathering in packs and unable to move.

Reply

just saying

8:24 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Open up a station 24 liberty green hook and ladder

Reply
Comment_arrow

Truth_Be_Told

10:12 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

if we had the man power... the township cut back on funding

Phil McCrackin

8:34 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Smokey u were probably in special Ed classes growing up because pennington wasn't even on the scene

Reply
Comment_arrow

Smokey

8:43 pm on Saturday, August 18, 2012

phil, personal attacks directed at me are expected; from you. But do not insult the courageous special needs people in this forum.

just saying

8:39 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Phill I respect your fails attempts to fight the red devil you sir are a great citizen not everyone can do it like we do at lindwood hose

Reply

Chris pangaldi

8:42 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Good call Phil !! FYI on arrival the fire building was a write off and the primary action was to protect the exposure buildings , oh and by the way smokey way to be a coward and hide behind a screen name, two thumbs up!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Smokey

8:45 pm on Saturday, August 18, 2012

chris, knowing my name would make a difference how?

Joe smith

8:46 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

So next time your car doesn't start and you cant get to work you better blame your self for it breaking. It's a piece of equipment and even with the most maint in the world things still fail. At least there was another truck to put in its place an do the job. Because of all this talk on the patch I stopped and talk to a lawrence twp firefighter today an happen to ask about the computer system like the cops have an they just don't have the funding

Reply

SHSB

8:48 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

One comment regarding training: developments were built near/around/behind the Dempster Fire Training Center, i.e., the Dempster Center was there first. Despite knowing they were buying a property next to a fire training center, the residents complained to Lawrence Township about the smoke and noise coming from the Dempster Center during live burn drills. Because of these complaints, live burn activities were significantly limited.(My husband's fire company actually goes all the way to Sayreville for live burn training now because they are rarely allowed to do live burns at Dempster any more in the evenings when volunteers usually train.

So now residents want to criticize the training levels of the volunteers after complaining about and forcing the curtailing of their live burn training activities in their own town and county.

Again, damned if you do, damned if you don't, even when the volunteers get all the appropriate training, even if it means traveling an hour out of the county.

Reply

Phil McCrackin

8:48 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Also smokey do u know how long it takes to lay a hose line?...if so and u think u can do better please join a fire company u would be our hero

Reply
Comment_arrow

Smokey

8:40 pm on Saturday, August 18, 2012

Evidently, laying the hose line is not the issue. The issue phil is training time for the volunteers. The volunteers @ LTFD need more time to connecting the hose line from the hydrant to the pumper truck, that could have feed the company at the scene water sooner and not later.
phil you seem to be a know it all, play the tapes back and count if you can the number of time the command demanded the water from the pumper truck.

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:21 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

So to the firefighters and first responders who are posting here can you let everyone know what it is that you know needs to be addressed if anything about this fire or did things go exactly as expected? Do you guys need more support from the community to get funding, training more volunteers, etc. You have a bunch of residents in this neighborhood who are currently pretty well motivated to help you guys get what you need.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

12:55 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Nice Try! You are the FIRST person who cut down the fire department in this article! To remind you, here's what you posted,
"assuming the official record is "accurate" it took them a long time to get water running from the fire hydrants into the fire engines and on to the house. I stood there for a good 15-20 minutes watching and waiting for them to start pumping significant amounts of water onto the fire. It was horrible watching the firefighters running a single hose of water from the ground for that 15-20 minutes before they got water running from 2 ladder trucks I suggest you to apologize for your comments, and post your contributions to the 3 fire companies in the township. I mean, it took SOOO Long"

So, what needs to be addressed is an apology from you and a donation. So you know, some volunteers are Professionals that are proficient in computers and can and will identify you for who you are!

Joanne Giambalvo

9:31 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Does anyone know what type of car went on fire

Reply

Chris pangaldi

9:33 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Things went as well as they could have considering the fire conditions we were met with on arrival. Are you that naive to think the dwelling could have been saved? Two additional dwellings were pretty much untouched due to the efforts of the Lawrence township firefighters ,great job to all!

Reply

barbara

9:35 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

I am sad this has gotten so nasty. We are neighbors,and we count on our fire fighters to help in time of need. I do not believe they didn't try to get here as fast as possible. I am sure they did not want to lose a house, but thankfully we didn't lose more than one and no lives were lost. What are we bitching about. I know I couldn't do better. I stood there and watched with my hand over my mouth in disbelief. I will not blame anyone, but I will do my best to help and make sure I continue to keep the road clear of vehicles so emergency vehicles can get there easily. Rather than criticizing, let's work as a team, keep the street clear and thank those that come to our rescue

Reply

Phil McCrackin

9:35 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

LGN... I can probably speak for the firefighters here and say MORE SUPPORT. U and a few others down them when they were trying their hardest and treating the scenario like it was there own house.

Reply

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:37 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

It was a Jeep Grand Cherokee I think.

Reply

Chris pangaldi

9:39 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Thanks Barbara,glad to see some support

Reply

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:43 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

@Phil McCrackin
Ok Phil firefighters and first responders need support but can you offer some specific things that we can do? The people closest to the issue usually have the best sense of what's working and what isn't. So how can we help?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chris pangaldi

9:52 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Your issue was response time right? Well I think that went out the window when documentation was produced. So what's your issue now? What could have changed? Do a little research on the Internet and then talk to me.

Comment_arrow

Mike Hawk

12:58 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Liberty Green - knock it off - We all know what you said. -liberty green: "So assuming the official record is "accurate" it took them a long time to get water running from the fire hydrants into the fire engines and on to the house. I stood there for a good 15-20 minutes watching and waiting for them to start pumping significant amounts of water onto the fire."

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:47 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

@Chris pangaldi
Chris I haven't stated that I thought the house could have been saved I was worried that the fire seemed to be burning out of control and was worried that it might get worse. If you're saying that my concerns are unfounded and you yourself are a first responder and can say definitively that it was under control then I will take you at your word. If things didn't go as well as expected and the volunteers need more support than let's make that happen.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chris pangaldi

10:02 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

The fire was contained to one dwelling with no additional extension, what else are you looking for?

Liberty Green Neighbor

9:59 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

@Chris pangaldi
As far as response time is concerned my issue there was not how quickly the firefighters responded when they were notified my concern was the time it took between 911 call being made and the fire dept getting notified about the 911 call. But SHSB offered a pretty comprehensive explanation there so thanks SHSB.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Chris pangaldi

10:08 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Ok well your earlier statements were a little different. If you require further assistance understanding how the whole process works then I would be happy to meet you for coffee to discuss it.

Billy

10:14 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Its hilarious what people argue about on this website.

Reply

Joanne Giambalvo

10:20 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

I asked about the car due to the fact that Ford Escape have a recall on them for catching fire and I was wondering if that was the cause. I am willing to do anything we need to help this family.. This is horrible..

Reply

LawrencevilleMom

10:26 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Civility has really gone out the window, hasn't it? The fire fighters did a fantastic job containing the fire. They are appreciated very much by most of us who live in Liberty Green. Unlike many people, they are using their "spare" time in a selfless way for the benefit of all. In any emergency, every minute feels like a lifetime. People are upset for the family. Once people calm down, I'm sure they will focus on more productive activity: donate to the family, get the parking rules changed, join the fire department. Action speaks louder than words.

Reply

Michele Hlewicki

11:32 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

http://mybigfatfamilyblog.wordpress.com/2012/08/14/burning/
as a lifelong resident if this town, i invite you to read what it feels like, from my point of view to serve and this town.
as friends of the family who just lost their home i would like you all to shut up and figure out a
productive way to help them. and at this point maybe the most productive thing you can do is shut up

Reply

One of You

11:49 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

First of all, it's a worst nightmare for anyone living in match boxes that we live in.

Everyone is grateful that no lives were lost and fire contained at one house. I know at least 3 people who live around / next to the unlucky house who swear the time it took for any real action to start. Please - this is not against any one person or the brave fire fighters, it is a combination of so many things which could have resulted in this response time...

I live in the same community and worry about these :

1. Will 25+ minutes be always the best time any other incident might get ?
2. Why has the parking been allowed on the curb, especially around the islands? Shouldn't it be against the fire code?
3. This is clearly an unacceptable overall response time (no offense to the brave firemen), but something is either wrong in the community's approach road design, I am hoping this is not the best response time

Fire fighters team, and specially the chiefs or anyone else who who is a senior person on the team, can something be done to improve the response time, keeping in mind how quickly the whole whole dwelling got charred down in this incident. I am again relieved that no one got seriously hurt, it could have been much worse and we need to know what can be done to make it better.

Reply

rc12

12:00 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

1.The response times clearly aren't much of an issue and under National standards by almost a minute. 2. The lack of water was because of the water supply system in this particular neighborhood.It is what is commonly referred to as a " loop" system, the water basically flows in a circle pattern in that neighborhood with only one main feeding it ,so when you open one hydrant and then one down the street you are using the same water and essentially "rob Peter to pay Paul". 3. The rapid fire spread in this house is because of the way these homes are constructed it is called light weight construction, truss construction and less the 2x4 construction allows the fire to spread quickly in these types of homes.There is not an issue with type of construction in being sub par it is the strongest way to build homes cost effectively but they do not stand up well to fire. Its a miracle that more than one house did not burn because in prior incidents around the country with this amount of fire the average loss is around 3 home. So how do you stop this from happening ? Push your legislators to for residential sprinklers or be pro active and get them installed yourself.Builders frequently block attempts to make residential sprinklers law because of cost but really it is minimal about an additional $500 per house. What really matters is that no one died and property can be replaced but the issues raised have been answered

Reply

A Guy

7:07 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Once again the response time was not an issue. You people keep bringing up the same points that have already been answered. Instead of talking about it on the website why don't you go to the township and complain. Leave the discussion of the fire service to the fire service personnel and the public safety committee. If you think you are an expert there are applications available at all 3 firehouses is for you to pick up, sign on the dotted line and apply.

Reply

Joe smith

8:23 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Thanks to pridesouthof95. I looked at some of the fire service websites. A fire doubles in size every min. My question is how long did it burn inside the house before any fire was showing for a person outside to see. All you people keep pointing fingers at the firefighters response time. The official records show there was zero problem with that and iam sure thats the same paperwork and times that would be used in court. So if your going to point finger (that's what your doing even if you say your not) call the police department and find out how the 911 call was transferred and handled. An another thing fire trucks arent giant rolling garden hoses that you flick a switch and you have water. They need to be set up and that may very well take a few mins. Stop looking at Facebook and do alittle reading on how things work

Reply

DarkDan

10:20 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

That's exactly it Joe. Some of these folks fail to realize that setting up big water requires big hose and big appliances. This takes time and manpower. It's not the usual bedroom fire where you can stretch a small line right in the door and you're on your way. Then add to it, the first couple of crews are assigned to the priority at that type of incident which are the houses next to the fire. So while it may look like not much is going on to get big water onto what the on lookers feel is the priority, that just isn't the case. I think those who have serious questions should look up an officer from the one of the fire companies and find out how things actually work. Ask them what they need and how things work for different types of incidents. I'm sure they would be more than happy to have more people on the same page.

Reply

22milesofBS

10:54 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

facts about the Lawrence Township fire service and problems associated with this specific fire...

- Lawrence Township's firefighting force is 100% volunteer in the evening, night, and weekend hours.
-Lawrence Township fire houses are not equipped with bunk rooms for members to stay overnight. Members will be responding from their homes in the middle of the night.
- the house on fire was located in the back of a large neighborhood that is not close to any firehouse.
-the closest firehouse located at Lawrence Sq., Village was closed due to lack of  volunteers to keep in operation
-As stated before newer construction houses such as these have the potential to collapse under fire conditions within five minutes
-although it took several minutes for LATER arriving firetrucks to supply the aerial master streams on top of the first arriving apparatus the exposures were protected within minutes of fire apparatus arrival due to hand lines operated by firefighters on the ground which will deliver 220 gallon per minute each. Enough to keep the neighbors houses from igniting.

Reply

22milesofBS

10:55 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

-tight streets, poor water system, and mechanical failure due to an aging fleet of apparatus were factors in the hindrance of establishing a SECONDARY and TERTIARY water supply within a timeframe greater than expected.
-when the fire department is faced with heavy fire conditions upon arrival such as this. It is the mission of the fire department to, not put water on the actual fire, but to protect exposures that are not involved in fire. To the laymen it may look as of the fire department is not doing their job because the fire continues to burn intensely in the original fire building, but in actuality firefighters had a handle on the fire almost immediately. It was this tactic that prevented the rest of the neighborhood from burning down.
-the firefighters successfully executed operations set forth by the officers running the incident in a timely manner. This is the reason why the fire did not go to a greater alarm aka a special call for more personnel and apparatus then initially anticipated. 
-All Lawrence Township firefighters and fire officers are trained to standards set by the New Jersey Division of Fire Safety.
-Parking is a minimal issue compared to the overall layout of the neighborhood. 
-the fire service is generally viewed as a walking, talking, living, breathing insurance policy and many people are not fans of paying insurance premiums. Volunteer firefighters in Lawrence Township generate a savings of 5%to 15% on property taxes.

Reply

Mike Hawk

11:14 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

This event is unfortunate. It always is very sad when someone loses their home, possessions (and in this case, dog) due to fire. Even with the official response and arrival statistics provided, blame is still being placed on the firefighters, shifting the complaints that “it took even longer” to “Put the wet stuff on the hot stuff”. It is amusing at best; that the very same Lawrence Residents, Patch.com Internet Trolls, vote down 2% budget increases, accept proposed Police and Fire Layoffs, yet complain when they need help and do not receive it in a timely manner – FOR FREE!!!!

Reply

Mike Hawk

11:15 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Imagine this scenario: Officer Sexton wasn’t in the area, because his position was eliminated or he was re-assigned to a high-crime area, who would have reported the “Real Fire” as opposed to the alarm? What if the volunteer firefighter decided that his/her 7am work conference call was more important than responding to another “malfunctioning” alarm in the middle of the night?

Reply
Comment_arrow

SHSB

11:25 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I have actually had to call my husband's boss and let him know that my husband is *still* out on a working fire call and I have no idea if and when he'll be at work that day. How many bosses and companies do you know of that would not tolerate that from their employees? I'm sure we can all think of or may have even had a boss or two that would have fired the employee for missing that conference call. Something else to think about before complaining about our volunteers--because in some cases they also risk their jobs when they risk their lives to volunteer.

SHSB

11:16 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

A few of you have asked what you can do to support us. I have a few suggestions:
--Let the restrictions on our training activities at Dempster be lifted or at least modified to allow more live burn training.
--Let the Township know that cutting our budget and personnel is unacceptable. (I have very vocally complained that there have been no cuts to activities at the Senior Center, yet they are cutting firefighter positions. Is having canasta AND yoga AND line dancing AND pinochle AND zumba for the seniors all more important than our fire service?)
--Consider volunteering at your local fire company. If you can't volunteer as a firefighter, consider helping with fundraising or making a donation.
--THANK us when we're out all night fighitng a fire in your neighborhood. Especially if it's on a weeknight and we have to show up at our paid jobs the next day.

Reply

Mike Hawk

11:18 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Congratulations should be given to the firefighters, that the two other homes didn't also succumb to the flames. Plastic siding sometimes melts. Knowing this development, it could have easily gone down like dominoes - one after another.

Reply

Jessie Mia O'Pinyun

12:01 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Thanks to our volunteers who responded about as quickly as can reasonably be expected, or quicker. Thanks to Mr. Ratcliffe for thoroughly documenting it for the public.

If we didn't make mistakes, there wouldn't be fires. Nobody is immune.

In the post-mortem, for those rightfully concerned with improving our safety and security, I suggest we go for some low-hanging fruit. One good place to start might be to consider:

http://firesprinklerinitiative.org/resources/fact-sheets/about-anti-sprinkler-legislation.aspx

You get what you pay for.

Reply

R Patel

3:43 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I witnessed the fire and salute the efforts made by the firefighters. I don't know why the response time of firefighters is being questioned when we know they wouldn't have stopped at Wawa to get a cup of coffee when the call came in. They got here as soon as humanly possible. It takes a lot of courage to hold the hose and advance towards the fire and it is very easy to hide behind an internet name and question everything because you pay few thousand dollar in taxes.
If you have serious concerns or questions or even suggestions, then please approach the municipality and engage yourself in the process. If you really feel so upset about the end to end process then you should get involved and initiate the change. It can be canvassing door to door to get extra funding for firefighters or initiating a signature campaign to ask township to make changes or ask friends and family to volunteer so that Lawrence Sq Blvd fire company can be reopened.
It is very easy to sit on a computer desk and criticize everything but it takes a lot to get out and make it happen.

Do you think you have what it takes or will you keep hiding behind your computer?

Reply

Billy

11:33 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

i am surprised they got there 11 minutes after dispatch. It takes me almost 3 minutes just from the beginning of the neighborhood to where the house is; because of the traffic pattern and bumps regardless of cars blocking the road, And I drive a sports car. And when did everyone become a fire expert to what the procedures are when arriving at a scene. Its not as simple as " HOLY CRAP FIRE Grab the hose and spray thousands of gallons of water (that needs to be pressurized mind you) and run into a house that was going to burn down regardless. What did you guys expect the outcome of this fire to be? The house was going to burn down period look at the size of the inferno for crying out loud. I am surprised there is still structure remaining and the neighbor's siding is not a pool of plastic on the ground. It is ALWAYS easier to criticize that do something about it. And why does 25 minutes keep being thrown around. there are OFFICIAL documents stating that it took 11 minutes for the first engine to arrive. Unless that has been some how falsified. I do not see the ongoing point of this discussion.

Patch you need to moderate your comments better. Although it brings you traffic 90% of this rambling is bs.

be the change you wish to see.

Reply

Leave a comment